Swiispa

Music Blog, Reviews, Rising Stars & Superstars

Joseph Schwartz – “John Henry v Tech Bro”: When Folk Music Meets Artificial Intelligence

There’s been a lot of buzz and hisses around AI, in fact we all know someone who thinks technology is gonna take over the world one day. When you jump online or even in real life, most arguments about artificial intelligence in music sound like two angry neighbors yelling over a fence. Some are worried robots are gonna steal jobs, then some too are are worried about AI writing songs, making art and perhaps even take over their playlists. On the music side of it, one side wants a robot to write every chorus in ten seconds, while the other side wants to smash every laptop with a sledgehammer. Chicago songwriter Joseph Schwartz looked at that standoff, and remembered the old tale of a railroad man racing a steam drill, and decided to turn the whole mess into a four-track EP.

 

The EP titled “John Henry v Tech Bro (all versions)” takes a classic Americana folk legend and brings it to our modern debates about AI. Now someone may say, if he’s bringing something into a digital world and it’s about a digital tool, then this gonna be more of technology assisted production, well your guess is right. He didn’t pretend technology doesn’t exist and hide behind traditional rules, Schwartz puts the tension right out in the open, and that’s the interesting part. He says, yeah this is what you talking about, how here it is, right here in the mix, listen and judge for yourself. The way he used modern generation tools heavily during his writing and arranging phase, running hundreds of passes before editing stems, tweaking lyrics, and finishing the mixes and mastering inside a standard digital audio workstation is quite commendablem he didn’t do the lazy one where people you just toss whatever they wanna hear to the machine and call it a day with any results that comes.

There’s a human edge to how it feels and it’s amazing. You know, taking one song and flipping it over 4x ain’t an easy work, because then you have to make sure they don’t sound the same, and I gotta say I like how he created them in different genres and the genre blending is very good. From folk storytelling to rock punch, pop hooks, and electronic textures. You get music where the drums hit with crisp weight, guitars bring edge when needed, and synthesizers add sheen without drowning out the human voice. Let’s take a look at how each track unfolds and then you can make your decision in this fight!

Welcoming listeners with a female vocals and version is the track “John Henry v Tech Bro – her version“. Using a female vocals in the lead track brings a different perspective to the famous tale, it also makes stage EP feels more like a conversation rather than a mere story told. It offers this dimension that everyone is having their say about it. It ain’t easy, sitting down create and make a whole song, sometimes it takes a lot of time than even intended, then imagine a tech bro stealing that piece within seconds and recreating it. You gonna freak out, and therefore you gonna do anything to protect your legacy. Just like henry said before he let a tech bro steal what he has, he would rather die with a pick in his arms! The beats are crisp, and each instrument is felt in this upbeat version.

Then comes “John Henry v Tech Bro“, the standard version. Now this version has a bit of bite in the instruments, you can feel the rage in the male vocals here, and the tempo is much more pacier. People always argue AI music has no soul and heart because it’s created by a machine with none of those, but what if it’s supervised by human? There’s a part in the story where John Henry beat the machine on streams with a million views, then the machine received an update and now it beats John, so the question is how do you fight something that keeps getting updated in every minute or seconds? The guitars are relentless here and drives the song with a lot of punch and it’s very lovely. In whatever the situation is, maybe there will be a neutral grounds, or can we say let people do what works for them and you do what works for you?

This version has added a different perspective to all the creations and it’s quite fascinating. “John Henry – synth pop” starts like a worship song, with that old lady vocals, shifts gears into bright electronic territory before transitioning into this pulsing synths and rhythmic drive giving the traditional folk roots a glossy, dance-friendly coat of paint. If you listen to this track, you might not even know Ai created it, so another question is, does a song’s emotional value depends on the tools used or the weight it carries? The different pitches of the vocals here is crazily good, it matches the emotions of each stage of the story and makes you feel every bit of it. So can something made with Ai assisted tools still connect with us? And this version will help you answer that question and it’s my favorite on the EP, it’s that good.

Then the fibal track “John Henry – punk pop” comes in and cranks up the speed and attitude. It’s more rebellious and moves with fast guitars, snappy percussion, and a lot of attitude. And I like how the energy in here turns an old-school folklore into something loud, scrappy, and built for movement. Just listen to those guitar riffs that starts the track, man, they are fierce and relentless, and has a vocals that matches that energy. It feels great and another track that you may not notice it was created with assisted tools. It’s more human and drives at you, moves you with a marching speed and makes you wanna jam to it all day!

Now the point of this release ain’t to settle the debate or every argument, it’s to spark a conversation and leave the verdict in your own hands. I like how Schwartz points out that even if John Henry beat the steam drill, he only defeated an early version of new machinery, and nobody today wants to go back to digging tunnels by hand. When you listen to the EP, you will realize how much of work was put into it, with over 1000 generations and human selections, he pushes both skeptics and enthusiasts to think past knee-jerk reactions and look at how tools actually change creative work. You can also feel that there was a lot experimenting and it also makes it clear that there’s a big difference in just asking the AI tool to make music and putting it out and asking it to make music and carefully mastering it, mixing it and selecting every bit of emotions and feeling and directing everything.

At the end of the day, maybe we all can agree that technology may help generate possibilities, but someone still has to make decisions about what works, what doesn’t and what the final piece should communicate and sound. Schwartz clearly understands why other musicians feel threatened by AI, but the question can fighting technological progress be won in the long term? I also like how “John Henry v Tech Bro (all versions)” brings different varieties of genres to the table, it helps tracks serve different purpose without loosing the main theme of the story. So go ahead and enjoy this piece, stream “John Henry v Tech Bro (all versions)” and make the decision for yourself!

Follow Joseph Schwartz on the links below for more;

Web Facebook SoundCloud YouTube Instagram Tiktok

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *